Email response from Dr. Ahmet Hoke of John Hopkins School of Medicine, School of Neurology - Specifically I asked him his opinion on three things:
1. What was his opinion of ETS in terms of risks vs benefits
2. His opinion on why Thoracic surgeons would advertise a surgical reversal approach when, as he sees it, it would have a very low probability of success
3. His opinion on the Davinci Robot Reversal article regarding surgical reattachment of the sympathetic nerves
1. It all depends on the risk benefit analysis, for some patients yes it may make sense as not everyone develops as severe side effects.
2. I think the surgeons may not be aware of the long term consequences of denervation.
The paper you refer to is not a good model of what happens to the patients because they cut the nerve and immediately repaired it. In such immediate repairs, the ganglia does not loose it's neurons and can regenerate. A better model would be to cut the nerves, wait 6 months and then do the repair; I suspect the recovery would be a lot less.Ahmet Hoke M.D., Ph.D. FRCPC
Professor of Neurology and Neuroscience
Director, Neuromuscular Division
Johns Hopkins School of Medicine
Department of Neurology
855 N. Wolfe St., Neurology 248
Baltimore, MD, 21205
USA
It’s not unusual to hear people describe themselves as emotionally 'colder'
It’s not unusual to hear people who have undergone sympathectomies describe themselves as feeling emotionally “colder” than before. Among psychologists and neurologists alike there is concern, but no evidence, that the procedure limits alertness and arousal as well as fear, and might affect memory, empathy and mental performance. Professor Ronald Rapee, the director of the Centre of Emotional Health at Sydney’s Macquarie University, says he’s counselled several people who complain of feeling “robot-like” in the long-term wake of the operation. “They’re happy they no longer blush, but they miss the highs and lows they used to feel.”
(John van Tiggelen, Good Weekend Magazine, The Age and the Sydney Morning Herald, 10th March 2012)
https://archive.today/uURge
(John van Tiggelen, Good Weekend Magazine, The Age and the Sydney Morning Herald, 10th March 2012)
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment